UK insurers lag on AI governance, Sapiens study finds
Thu, 19th Nov 2026 (Today)
UK insurers lack fully operational AI governance strategies, according to research published by Sapiens, with the gap widest among specialist and mid-sized insurers.
The study found that 29% of UK insurers have a fully operational AI governance strategy. Among specialist and mid-sized firms, that falls to 9%. It also found that 58% of UK respondents expect AI to become fully autonomous in insurance within the next two to three years.
The findings come from the Sapiens Insurance AI Maturity Index, a survey by Research in Finance of 475 senior insurance professionals across the UK and Ireland, the Nordics, Benelux, South Africa and North America. The research included 95 senior insurance professionals in each region, spanning transformation leaders and business users across life and property and casualty insurance.
The data points to a divide between ambition and preparedness in the UK market. Insurers classified in the index as Autonomous Leaders were far more likely to have mature governance arrangements in place, with 80% reporting fully operational policies.
Governance gap
The survey suggests governance has become a key marker of AI maturity in insurance as firms test more advanced forms of decision-making. While many UK respondents said they trust AI outputs, fewer appeared confident that the oversight structures around those systems are complete.
Among UK insurers using AI, 81% said they are confident in the decisions made by AI and agentic AI. That compares with 86% of international respondents and 95% of Autonomous Leaders.
At the same time, one in 10 UK respondents said they are not confident in the checks used to monitor AI and agentic AI decision-making. Among Autonomous Leaders, the figure was 2%.
Compliance and policy requirements also remain a major reason for human intervention. Asked why AI decisions are overridden, 62% of UK insurers cited compliance and policy requirements, compared with 52% of Autonomous Leaders.
That emphasis on oversight may be contributing to stronger monitoring in some areas. More than half of UK respondents, 53%, said they can detect misaligned AI and agentic AI decision-making either in near real time or in less than two weeks.
There were also differences between market segments. Property and casualty insurers were slightly ahead of life insurers on this measure, with 54% of property and casualty insurers and 48% of life insurers saying they can identify misalignments within two weeks.
Specialist and mid-sized insurers performed better than some larger peers on detection despite lagging on formal governance. The survey found that 65% could spot misaligned decision-making within two weeks, compared with 46% of major insurance organisations.
Human oversight
The UK also appears more cautious than some other markets about removing people from decision loops altogether. The survey found that 23% of UK respondents said there will always be human involvement in AI-driven insurance operations, compared with 9% in the Nordics and 7% in Benelux.
That may reflect a market still building its governance model while trying to balance innovation with regulatory and operational control. The study defines AI governance as clear accountability, effective monitoring, robust controls and human oversight.
For smaller insurers, the issue carries added weight. The research argues that specialist and mid-sized firms may be able to adapt faster than larger institutions because they face fewer legacy technology constraints, but that advantage depends on putting governance structures in place early.
"Strong governance must be a priority, not an afterthought, and our research highlights a significant opportunity, particularly for UK specialist and mid-size firms that are behind on this," said Paul Wheeler, Chief Executive Officer at Sapiens.
"These firms can be more agile than their larger counterparts and should invest in doing the vital governance groundwork now, so they are better positioned to take advantage of the technology and drive long-term business value over the next couple of years," Wheeler added.