CMOtech UK - Technology news for CMOs & marketing decision-makers
United Kingdom
AI-tagged TikTok posts in Britain draw less engagement

AI-tagged TikTok posts in Britain draw less engagement

Fri, 20th Nov 2026 (Today)
Regine Laguilles
REGINE LAGUILLES Editor

Kolsquare has found that AI-tagged TikTok posts in the UK attract less engagement than content from human creators. The study points to a 17% to 24% gap across key European markets.

The influencer marketing platform analysed 87,362 AI-tagged posts from more than 20,000 creators worldwide and compared them with non-AI posts published by the same influencers over a year. Across the global sample, AI-tagged organic posts generated 5.5% less engagement. On TikTok, the gap widened to 21.2%.

Instagram showed a much narrower gap of 1%, suggesting audiences on short-form video platforms react more negatively to AI-labelled material than users on image-led networks. In Britain, the findings add to questions over whether brands can use artificial intelligence to cut production time and costs without weakening the connection between creators and their audiences.

Quentin Bordage, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Kolsquare, said: "Influence works because a real person has built an engaged community over time and those people trust in their authenticity. An avatar can copy the look and the tone, but it has never lived what it recommends. Take the person away, and you're left with advertising."

The figures come as marketers expand the use of artificial intelligence in influencer campaigns. Kolsquare's broader research found that 84% of influencer marketers and 72% of creators surveyed already use AI or automation tools for tasks including campaign planning, audience analysis, scripting and video editing.

That uptake has not yet translated into consistent returns, according to research cited in the report. A Bain survey referenced by Kolsquare found that 95% of organisations surveyed use AI, but only 6% said it delivers substantial results.

Consumer scepticism

Audience concerns over synthetic content may help explain the gap. Research from Canva and DoubleVerify cited in the report found that 78% of consumers prefer advertising created by humans, while 42% said poor-quality AI advertising damages their opinion of a brand.

More than half of consumers also said they cannot consistently identify AI-generated content. That creates a difficult balance for brands that want to adopt AI tools without losing the trust of audiences who may resent undisclosed or low-quality synthetic material.

The report argues that AI may prove more useful behind the scenes than in front-facing creator output. In one experiment cited in the study, influencer marketing agency BeInfluence compared creators selected by AI with those chosen by its human team.

The AI selected two larger influencers to meet reach targets. The agency's staff chose smaller creators who delivered similar reach, connected with different audiences and produced higher engagement.

According to the report, the results show the limits of systems that can measure follower counts and engagement data but struggle to assess personality, credibility, and the relationship between a creator and their audience. It also supports a wider argument in the influencer sector that data-led selection does not always reflect how audiences respond in practice.

Back-office role

Even so, the use of AI in campaign operations appears to be growing. BeInfluence said it previously spent 90% of its campaign analysis time gathering data and 10% interpreting it, but after integrating Kolsquare's AI-connected tools, it reduced data extraction to 30%.

That shift freed up more time for strategy and interpretation. For agencies under pressure to handle larger creator rosters and more performance reporting, those efficiency gains may be easier to justify than replacing creators with AI-generated output.

The research also points to changes in how consumers research products. Kolsquare cited McKinsey findings showing that 38% of consumers surveyed across the UK, France and Germany now use AI to research products or make purchasing decisions.

Among those consumers, 63% use AI to compare brands, prices and reviews. That could increase the value of creator content that answers detailed product questions, particularly if AI search tools draw on those videos and reviews when producing recommendations.

Kolsquare also cited research showing that 60% of YouTube videos referenced by AI in US consumer goods and automotive searches came from creators. The finding suggests influencer content may continue shaping purchase decisions long after a paid campaign has ended, especially when it offers product demonstrations or in-depth reviews rather than brief, attention-driven clips.

Regulatory gap

The study also highlights a difference in disclosure rules between Britain and the European Union. While the EU has introduced specific deepfake disclosure requirements for AI content, Britain has no equivalent blanket legal requirement to label AI-generated material.

Brands still face existing UK advertising and consumer protection rules if content misleads consumers. That leaves companies to decide how much transparency is needed to protect trust as the use of synthetic media grows.

Kolsquare said it has published an AI Manifesto under which it will not develop technology that clones real creators or promotes virtual influencers. Bordage said: "There's a lot of AI washing in our industry, but underneath it, this is a real revolution. In a few months, the way brands select creators, brief them and measure what they deliver has changed more than in the previous five years."